The Commodity Move Everyone Wants to Fade.. and Why the Data Says Don't.


DBC is up 30% year to date.

Let that sit for a second. The Invesco DB Commodity Index is up 30% in a little over three months. Against the S&P 500, it is up 35%. And most people I talk to think the trade is done.

They think this is the top. They think commodities have run too far too fast. They want to fade it and rotate back into tech.

I think they are wrong.

Two months ago I wrote about DBC hitting 3 year highs. The thesis was simple.. broad commodity strength leads, individual names follow.

I showed you that $7.5 billion flowed into natural resource funds in January alone. The largest single month inflow ever recorded. Institutions were already positioning before geopolitics gave them cover.

The divergence between DBC and crude oil was closing fast. And the reflexive loop I described in The Reflexivity Trap was playing out in real time.

If you missed that piece, here it is: DBC at 3 Year Highs. Here’s What That Means for Oil.

Everything I laid out in February has continued. DBC didn’t pull back. It accelerated higher.

Now our analyst Randy just pulled the historical data on what happens after a move like this. He went back to 2007 and found only 4 other instances where DBC put up this kind of YTD performance by early April.

Here is the part that matters.

In every case, the initial signal led to continuation. Not reversal. The big tops.. the real climax tops.. came later. On the second signal. Not the first.

We are on the first signal.

That doesn't mean you blindly chase. It means the historical pattern says this type of move has more room to run before it exhausts itself. People calling for a top right now are early. The data says they are early by months, not days.

And energy is only part of the story. That's the other thing people get wrong.

They see oil headlines and assume the whole commodity complex is a crude oil trade. It's not.

Agriculture is trending. Metals are trending. Energy is trending. The breadth across the commodity space is wide.

When you see all three sectors moving together like this, it tells you something real is happening underneath. One commodity is not dragging an index higher. This is a broad based move.

I flagged this two months ago based on flows and price structure. Randy just confirmed it with nearly 20 years of historical data. The thesis hasn't changed. If anything, it got stronger.

Randy’s full breakdown with the historical comps, the charts, and the data behind all of this is available to members inside today’s report. If you want to see exactly what happened in those 4 prior instances and what it means for positioning right now, that's where you will find it.

Profits Over Prophets,

Hamilton

PS.. If you have been reading these free newsletters and wondering what the paid side looks like.. this is it. Randy’s commodity research, my weekly reports, the flow data, and the full trade setups. Market Blueprint members get all of it. Join here.

The Trading Initiative

If you’re looking for macro takes, CNBC headlines, or excuses for why nothing works — you’re in the wrong place. The Trading Initiative is where real traders come to level up. We don’t chase news. We don’t follow narratives. We follow price. Led by Hamilton, TTI teaches traders how to identify trends, isolate relative strength, and capture momentum like professionals. If you’re ready to stop second-guessing and start trading like it’s your business, this is where you belong.

Read more from The Trading Initiative

NVDA vs MAGS just broke out to new highs. After nearly two years of nothing.. the king of all stocks is leading the Mag 7 higher again. Think about that.. Nvidia vs Mag-7, NVDA/MAGS, Weekly The last time NVDA lead higher in this ratio was April 2023. You might remember what happened next. From April 2023 to June 2024: QQQ ran 55%. NVDA ran nearly 400%. The semiconductor industry group ran over 125%. That's not a rally. That's a regime. Here's why this matters.. the NVDA/MAGS ratio is the...

Intel (INTC) is at all-time highs afterhours. September 2025. INTC broke $26 and the Flow Score triggered a buy on a name nobody wanted. We opened the first position.. targeted the January 2026 contracts.. and we've been in the trade continuously ever since. Not a new call. Not a fresh trade. A continuous position held through one of the most hated stocks on the tape. Seventeen days ago I wrote a piece called They Bought The Tech Sector Last Week. I showed you the data. Seven tech names in...

EEM is up 13.6% year to date. SPY is up 1.7%. Let that sit for a second. The thing nobody wanted to own.. the thing that underperformed for a decade.. the thing your advisor told you to ignore.. is lapping the S&P 500 by nearly 12 percentage points this year. And the gap is accelerating. Not AI. Not mega-cap tech. Not the Magnificent 7. Emerging markets. Here's why this matters.. Two months ago I wrote a piece called Smart Money Is Diversifying Outside of the USA. In it, I showed the EEM/SPY...